Hidden defects and liability: The guide to secure your real estate purchase

Buying real estate is the investment of a lifetime. However, a hidden structural crack or an infested frame can turn your dream into a financial nightmare. As a real estate hunter, my role is to find the invisible. But when the defect appears after signing, you need to master the rules of the guarantee of hidden defects. Find out how to define responsibility, what your remedies are, and how to get redress without compromising your health.

‍

1. Define the hidden defect: The essential legal criteria

Article 1641 of the Civil Code strictly regulates this concept. A simple defect is not enough to engage the seller's liability. To succeed, you need to prove that the problem meets specific criteria.

‍

An invisible defect during visits

The vice must be stashed. If the problem was apparent during your visits or mentioned in the technical diagnostics, you cannot invoke this guarantee. The buyer must be vigilant, but he is not supposed to dismantle the partitions to check the condition of the pipes.

‍

An asset rendered unfit for use

The defect must be of such severity that it makes the house uninhabitable or reduces its use so much that you would not have bought it, or at a much lower price. We are talking here about fragile foundations, serious structural humidity or a major non-compliance of the electrical network.

‍

The antecedence of the defect to the sale

It is the most difficult point to prove. The defect must exist at the time you signed the authentic instrument. If it is the result of a lack of maintenance on your part after purchase, the warranty does not apply. Expertise is often indispensable here.

‍

2. Seller's responsibility: Individual vs Professional

The law does not treat all sellers the same way. Depending on the profile of the person who transfers the property to you, your legal protection varies considerably.

‍

The clause for the exemption of hidden defects

In 95% of compromises between individuals, a clause states that “the seller does not guarantee the buyer against hidden defects”. It is a great protection for the non-professional seller. To get rid of this clause, you need to prove that the seller knew about the defect and deliberately kept it hidden from you. That's what we call the Bad faith.

‍

The increased responsibility of the professional seller

If you buy from a property dealer or a developer, the situation changes. The law considers that he necessarily knows the faults of the property. He cannot absolve himself of his responsibility. He is presumed to be acting in bad faith if he sells you a faulty item. For more details on your rights, consult the official site Service-public.fr.

‍

The role of the real estate agent and the notary

The real estate agent has a duty to advise. If he is aware of a defect and does not inform you, he may be held liable. The notary must ensure the legal validity of the transaction, but he does not visit the property. Its role remains limited to the drafting of guarantee clauses.

‍

3. Procedure and remedies: How to obtain redress?

Have you discovered a problem? Don't freak out. Act methodically to build a solid case before the courts or during an amicable negotiation.

‍

The two-year action period

You have a period of 2 years from the discovery of the defect (and not the purchase) to take action. However, an overall limit of 20 years after sale generally applies. Do not delay as soon as you notice a serious anomaly.

‍

Compulsory adversarial expertise

Before taking legal action, call in a building expert. It will confirm the nature of the vice and its antecedence. For this proof to be enforceable, it should ideally be carried out in a contradictory manner, by inviting the seller to be present or represented. This is a key step in our [suspicious link removed].

‍

Prohibitory action or estimatory action

You have two options. The redhibitory action allows you to return the property and to have the price and notary fees reimbursed in full. The estimatory action allows you to keep the house but to obtain a partial reimbursement corresponding to the cost of the work or the loss of value.

‍

Conclusion: Anticipate to never suffer

The guarantee against hidden defects is a powerful protection but difficult to activate because of the exemption clause between individuals. Anticipation is the best defense. By using a real estate hunter, you benefit from an expert eye from the first visit. We analyze the minutes of the general meeting, the diagnoses and the structural state to remove doubts.

To find out more about securing your projects, read our others blog posts.

‍

FAQ: Quick answers to your questions

Can I sue the seller for a broken boiler 6 months after purchase?

‍If the failure is due to normal wear and tear, no. If the seller knew that the heater was pierced and hidden it, yes. Everything depends on the proof of precedence and the knowledge of the defect by the seller.

How much does a hidden defect procedure cost?

‍Count between €3,000 and €8,000 including lawyer fees and legal expertise. It is a heavy investment, which is why it is useful to try an amicable mediation beforehand.

Is an erroneous technical diagnosis a hidden defect?

‍No, it's a diagnostic error. In this case, you must engage the responsibility of the diagnoser and his professional insurance, and not that of the seller (unless there is complicity).